See other homes in:
Primary listing photo
Listing photo 2
Listing photo 3
Listing photo 4
Listing photo 5

89 Poplar Street, Garden City, NY, 11530

5beds
3baths
2,670sqft
$1,899,000
$711price/sqft
$13,307/moest. monthly cost
$532,280/yrincome needed

About This Home

Welcome home to 89 Poplar Street in Garden City, a beautifully renovated 5-bedroom, 2.5-bath Tudor set on a private 60' x 125' lot. Offering approximately 2,700 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this exceptional home seamlessly blends timeless architectural charm with modern updates and everyday comfort. The inviting main level features a vestibule entry, a formal living room with a wood-burning fireplace and new Pella windows, a spacious dining room, and a new kitchen appointed with Viking appliances, Porcelanosa cabinetry and flooring, a custom hood, and glass doors that open to an expansive patio and beautiful backyard—perfect for indoor-outdoor entertaining. A newly renovated powder room and a bright sunroom/family room complete the first floor. Upstairs, the second level offers a sun-lit primary bedroom with the potential to add an en-suite bath (shell & plumbing already in place), three additional bedrooms, and a beautifully renovated hall bath with both a shower and tub. The walk-up third floor provides exceptional bonus living space, featuring a comfortable lounge, a fifth bedroom, and a full bathroom—ideal for guests or a home office. Additional highlights include: basement with recreation rooms and a separate laundry area, a detached two-car garage, brand new driveway, ductless air conditioning, hardwood floors throughout, and an unbeatable location close to Locust School, Grove Park, and the LIRR. This exceptional home truly has it all!

Getting Around

61
WalkingSomewhat Walkable
46
TransitSome Transit
45
BikeSomewhat Bikeable

Schools

--
Locust SchoolGrades K-10.3 mi
10/10
10/10
Garden City High SchoolGrades 9-121.9 mi

Construction

Condition

  • Year built: 1928

Materials

  • Construction materials: Stucco

Type & Style

  • Home type: SingleFamily
  • Architectural style: Tudor
  • Property subType: Single Family Residence,Residential

Interior

Appliances

  • Appliances included: Dishwasher,Dryer,Gas Oven,Gas Range,Refrigerator,Washer,Gas Water Heater

Basement

  • Has basement: Yes
  • Basement: Full

Bathroom1

  • Level: First

Bathroom2

  • Level: Second

Bathroom3

  • Level: Third

Bathroom4

  • Level: Second

Bedroom2

  • Level: Second

Bedroom3

  • Level: Second

Bedroom5

  • Level: Third

Bedrooms & Bathrooms

  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Bathrooms: 3
  • Full bathrooms: 2
  • 1/2 bathrooms: 1

Den

  • Level: First

Dining Room

  • Level: First

Features

  • First Floor Full Bath,Chefs Kitchen,Crown Molding,Entrance Foyer,Formal Dining,His and Hers Closets,Original Details,Soaking Tub,Storage
  • Number of fireplaces: 1
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Attic: Walkup

Heating & Cooling

  • Heating features: Natural Gas,Steam
  • Cooling features: Ductless,Wall/Window Unit(s)

Interior Area

  • Total structure area: 2,670
  • Total interior livable area: 2,670 sqft

Kitchen

  • Level: First

Living Room

  • Level: First

Master Bedroom

  • Level: Second

Property

Details

  • Parcel number: 2011341220001200
  • Special condition: None

Lot

  • Lot size: 7,500 sqft
  • Lot size dimensions: 60 x 125

Parking

  • Total spaces: 2
  • Parking features: Detached,Driveway,Garage
  • Has garage: Yes
  • Attached garage spaces: 2
  • Covered spaces: 2
  • Has uncovered spaces: Yes

Climate Risk is Financial Risk

Every home has a financial story beyond the listing price. Below, you’ll see the climate risks that could affect this property — and in Bills & Affordability, how those risks may influence repairs, insurance, utilities, and long-term value.

Biggest Threats for This Home

  • Inland Flooding
    Inland FloodingModerate
  • Ice Storm
    Ice StormModerate
  • Winter Weather
    Winter WeatherModerate
  • Tsunami
    TsunamiInsufficient Data

How This Home’s Risks Compare

Inland Flooding
Ice Storm
Winter Weather
Tsunami

FEMA Declared Disasters in Nassau County and New York

Flood
Severe Storm
Snowstorm

Understanding the Costs

Financial advisors generally recommend spending no more than 30% of your gross household income on housing costs. In practice, many households stretch to 35% or beyond — especially in high-cost markets.

Estimated Costs Today

MonthlyAnnual
Mortgage $9,602$115,224
Home Insurance *$543$6,516
Property Taxes $2,721$32,652
Electricity $441$5,294
Total$13,307$159,684
*Does not include cost of any FAIR Plan premiums

Income You'd Need if You Spent...

35% on housing$456,240/yr
40% on housing$399,210/yr
45% on housing$354,853/yr

New York FAIR Plan Programs

New York Property Insurance Underwriting Association

Covered
WildfireWildfire
HailHail
WindWind
Visit Website →
Current Policies
Residential: 20,669Commercial: 1,556
Total Premiums$32.27M
Total Exposure$7.63B

How Costs Could Change Over Time

Climate risk is quickly impacting all of the major home ownership costs. Adjust the growth rates and percentage of income spent on housing below to see how your housing costs could change over the next 10 years — and what income you'd need to keep up.

Insurance Growth Rate5-year average: 6.4%
6.4%
0%30.0%
Electricity Growth Rate10-year average: 7.1%
7.1%
0%15.0%
Property Taxes Growth Rate2-year average: 1.0%
1.0%
0%15.0%
Income Spent on Housing
30%
30%45%

Comparing Against the Market

Price Per Sq Ft

$711This listing

vs Other Active Listings

Avg $/sqft

ZIP 11530$615
Nassau County$567

vs Homes Sold Last Month

Median $/sqft

ZIP 11530$629
Nassau County$510

Current Market Trends

Median Price Per Square Foot

The median price per square foot of homes sold in this area each month. Compare this to this listing's price per square foot to gauge whether the home is priced in line with recent sales.

Historicals for This Listing

Zestimate History ($/sqft)

Price History

DateEventPrice
2026-07-23Listed for sale$1,899,000
2010-09-30Sold$760,000

For Sale by Agent

AgentJennifer Sullivan
BrokerageCompass Greater NY LLC

Similar Homes