35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706
About This Home
Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer. This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.
Getting Around
Somewhat Walkable
Very Limited Transit
BikeableSchools
Construction
Condition
- Year built: 1890
Materials
- Construction materials: Cedar
Type & Style
- Home type: SingleFamily
- Architectural style: Other
- Property subType: Single Family Residence,Residential
Interior
Appliances
- Appliances included: Dishwasher,Disposal,Dryer,Electric Oven,Gas Cooktop,Gas Oven,Gas Range,Refrigerator,Stainless Steel Appliance(s),Trash Compactor,Washer,Gas Water Heater,Wine Refrigerator
Basement
- Level: Basement
Basement
- Has basement: Yes
- Basement: Full,Partially Finished
Bathroom1
- Level: First
Bathroom2
- Level: Second
Bathroom3
- Level: Third
Bedroom1
- Level: Second
Bedroom2
- Level: Second
Bedroom3
- Level: Second
Bedroom4
- Level: Second
Bedroom5
- Level: Second
Bedrooms & Bathrooms
- Bedrooms: 9
- Bathrooms: 5
- Full bathrooms: 4
- 1/2 bathrooms: 1
Den
- Level: First
Dining Room
- Level: First
Features
- Eat-in Kitchen,Entrance Foyer,Formal Dining,Primary Bathroom,Storage
- Number of fireplaces: 4
- Fireplace: Yes
- Attic: Storage
Heating & Cooling
- Heating features: Has Heating (Unspecified Type)
- Cooling features: Ductless,Wall/Window Unit(s)
Interior Area
- Total structure area: 5,646
- Total interior livable area: 5,646 sqft
Kitchen
- Level: First
Living Room
- Level: First
Master Bathroom
- Level: Second
Master Bedroom
- Level: Second
Other
- Level: First
Other
- Level: First
Other
- Level: First
Other
- Level: First
Other
- Level: Third
Property
Details
- Parcel number: 0500394000200027000
- Special condition: None
- Exclusions: Kitchen/Dining Room Chandeliers/Sconces in Sunroom
Features
- Levels: Three Or More
- Patio & porch: Deck,Porch
Lot
- Lot size: 1.40 Acres
Parking
- Total spaces: 3
- Parking features: Garage
- Has garage: Yes
- Attached garage spaces: 3
- Covered spaces: 3
Climate Risk is Financial Risk
Every home has a financial story beyond the listing price. Below, you’ll see the climate risks that could affect this property — and in Bills & Affordability, how those risks may influence repairs, insurance, utilities, and long-term value.
Biggest Threats for This Home
- Coastal Flooding
- Winter Weather
- Cold Wave
- Hurricane
- Inland Flooding
- Lightning
- Strong Wind
- Tsunami
How This Home’s Risks Compare
FEMA Declared Disasters in Suffolk County and New York
Understanding the Costs
Financial advisors generally recommend spending no more than 30% of your gross household income on housing costs. In practice, many households stretch to 35% or beyond — especially in high-cost markets.
Estimated Costs Today
| Monthly | Annual | |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage | $9,860 | $118,320 |
| Home Insurance * | $764 | $9,168 |
| Property Taxes | $2,632 | $31,584 |
| Electricity | $933 | $11,196 |
| Total | $14,189 | $170,268 |
Income You'd Need if You Spent...
New York FAIR Plan Programs
How Costs Could Change Over Time
Climate risk is quickly impacting all of the major home ownership costs. Adjust the growth rates and percentage of income spent on housing below to see how your housing costs could change over the next 10 years — and what income you'd need to keep up.
Comparing Against the Market
Price Per Sq Ft
vs Other Active Listings
Avg $/sqft
vs Homes Sold Last Month
Median $/sqft
Current Market Trends
Median Price Per Square Foot
The median price per square foot of homes sold in this area each month. Compare this to this listing's price per square foot to gauge whether the home is priced in line with recent sales.
Historicals for This Listing
Zestimate History ($/sqft)
Price History
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-04-30 | Price change | $1,950,000 |
| 2026-04-10 | Listed for sale | $1,999,999 |
| 2025-12-18 | Listing removed | $1,999,999 |
| 2025-09-19 | Price change | $1,999,999 |
| 2025-05-21 | Listed for sale | $2,350,000 |
| 2013-06-17 | Sold | $1,150,000 |
| 2012-04-28 | Listing removed | $1,300,000 |
| 2012-02-17 | Listed for sale | $1,300,000 |
| 2010-09-24 | Listing removed | $1,500,000 |
| 2010-06-26 | Price change | $1,500,000 |
| 2009-03-28 | Listed for sale | $1,700,000 |
| 2009-01-01 | Listing removed | $1,900,000 |
| 2008-07-12 | Listed for sale | $1,900,000 |
For Sale by Agent
View on Zillow